Pleading Not Guilty In Insein

 

Introduction
In mid-November 1995, the authorities at Insein Prison in Rangoon raided the cells of 22 political prisoners. Following the raids the prisoners were interrogated, and some were beaten, tortured and held in tiny cells usually kept for prison dogs.

Among these prisoners were prominent journalist U Win Tin, magazine publisher Myo Myint Nyein, and National League for Democracy (NLD) parliamentarians U Hla Than and Dr. Zaw Myint Maung, both of whom won seats in the 1990 election.

As a result of the raids the prison authorities alleged they seized 'seditious' material that was 'damaging' to the SLORC regime. These magazines included pro-democracy magazines, short stories and poems; Time and Newsweek magazines; transcripts of news items from the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), Voice of America (VOA) and Democratic Voice of Burma (DVB); and letters to Aung San Suu Kyi, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and the United Nations.

Each of the 22 prisoners was subsequently charged under Section 5 (E) of the 1950 Emergency Provision Act (see Appendix III) for writing and distributing allegedly false information. If found guilty of this charge a person can be jailed for up to seven years and receive a fine. The law states that to receive a conviction a person must either know that the information distributing was not correct, or there must be enough evidence to show the information was not correct.

Among the materials seized was a letter to former Special Rapporteurs to Burma Professor Yokota, which contained information about conditions inside Insein Prison. Insein is the oldest and also the largest of Burma's 36 prisons, and is the country's most notorious in terms of human rights abuses. Nearly all of Burma well known political prisoners have spent some time there. The trail of these 22 prisoners was held inside Insein Prison.

The prisoners were refused access to legal counsel at the trail and they defended themselves. All 22 prisoners pleaded not guilty to the charge brought against them, either on the grounds that what they had written was the truth or that the charge was false. As a statement to their courage the prisoners spoke out against the authorities, complaining of torture and beatings in prison, and calling for prisoners' rights and for access to legal counsel. Some also accused the authorities of holding the political trail and criticized the handling of the trail and the presentation of the evidence.

This case was specifically mentioned in an interim United Nations report on human rights in Burma as an example of the denial of freedom of expression in prisons. The report, complained by the UN Special Rapporteurs of the Commission on Human Rights, Judge Rajsoomer Lallah, stated that '20 prisoners' were 'allegedly tried and given additional sentences of 5 to 7 years' (see Appendix I). However, according to the official report of the trail, translated here, 22 prisoners were tried and they all received a additional seven years with hard labor.

Since the trail, U Hla Than has died in custody. His death certificate states that he died of pulmonary tuberculosis. His request to be allowed to die at home was rejected reportedly because he refused to resign from the NLD. The other 21 political prisoners are still being held in Insein Prison.